Research Update from the Serpentine Grasslands: Pollinators in a Rare and Endangered Habitat

Did you know that before European colonization and thanks to native land management, the area that is now northern Maryland was home to thousands of acres of sprawling prairie-like grasslands? It’s a pretty cool thing to imagine, right? Instead of dense urban centers, highways, farms, and patches of forest, most of Baltimore County would’ve been a nearly treeless ocean of swaying grasses and wildflowers! Instead of cars, shopping carts, and the hustle and bustle of people, you’d see majestic herds of deer and elk, a horizon dotted with flocks of birds, and the busyness of bees and butterflies. You can read more in a previous blog post about these eastern ‘Serpentine Grasslands’. Sadly, these grasslands no longer exist in the formerly massive extent they used to occupy, but several preserved remnants still endure here in Maryland to tell the tale of their former glory!

a view of the Maryland Serpentine Grasslands on a cloudy day
A stormy summer evening at Soldiers Delight Natural Environment Area, Baltimore Co. – one of Maryland’s Serpentine preservation areas. Photo: Justin O’Neill

What is the current status of the Maryland Serpentine Grasslands?

Many historic and contemporary human-driven environmental changes have caused these special ecosystems to dwindle to the point of concern; it is currently estimated that only 1.6% of their historic area in the region remains. This precipitous decline of eastern Serpentine Grasslands is concerning because they support many special plant species that are considered threatened or rare in Maryland. Luckily, several private and governmental organizations have taken to conserving and studying these ecosystems in Maryland and elsewhere (check out some of them here: Soldiers Delight and Lake Roland). Although eastern Serpentine grasslands have attracted considerable scientific research interest in terms of their rare and unique plant life, the animals that call these critically imperiled habitats home are virtually undocumented (with the exception of some rare butterflies and moths). Could there be special Serpentine associated species that we have yet to even notice?

a purple wildflower found in the Maryland Serpenine Grasslands
Phemeranthus teretifolius, the Quill Fameflower, is one of the special plants that makes its home on the dry and rocky soils of Serpentine habitats. The flower is only open during a few short hours in the afternoon, during which it is abuzz with small solitary bees. Photo: Justin O’Neill

The mission of knowing what lives there to better protect it

To address this knowledge gap, our team at the EspíndoLab, have set out to start documenting the insects present in Maryland’s Serpentine Grasslands. Our current focus is on flower-visiting insects that could act as pollinators, specifically bees and hoverflies. Given the many rare and threatened plants documented in these areas, we figured it was important to first know what insects might be helping most with Serpentine plant reproduction. 

How do we do this?

To document these flower-visiting insects, the lab crew has undertaken 5 years (2019 – 2023) of observations and insect collection in three of Maryland’s most intact Serpentine Grassland conservation areas. Because different flowers bloom during different parts of the growing season (spring to fall), we had to visit these conservation areas many times each year to observe the full range of flowering plants and their insect visitors. So, once every two to three weeks across each season, the Serpentine squad would head out to visit our many field study sites and systematically capture bees and hoverflies seen interacting with flowers. Currently, we are working on the meticulous process of examining each captured specimen with a microscope to determine its species identity using taxonomic guides.

a student researcher collecting insects at the Maryland Serpentine Grasslands
Nets at the ready! The Serpentine squad carefully captures bees and hoverflies seen visiting flowers at several study sites across three of Maryland’s Serpentine conservation areas. Photo: Justin O’Neill

With this information we can begin to catalog the insect species that make up Serpentine pollination communities. This allows us to explore if the communities present in the Serpentines are different from those in nearby habitats and if they possess any rare or unique species. This information will also give us insight on how the plant and pollinator communities interact with one another; informing us about key species that contribute vitally to pollinator persistence or plant reproduction. Ultimately, the knowledge we gain will provide a baseline understanding about the dynamics of pollinator diversity in the grasslands and inform the organizations that conserve and restore these ecosystems.

What are we learning?

So far, the EspíndoLab’s efforts in the grasslands have revealed quite a bit about the broad array of insects that visit these unique plant communities. Notably, among the myriad of beetles, butterflies, flies, and wasps that visit Serpentine flowers, native solitary bees and hoverflies are consistently observed to be the most abundant – and perhaps most important potential pollinators. Interestingly, social bee species, particularly honey bees, that are commonly observed in many pollination communities, were infrequently encountered in our collecting efforts until late in the season, if it all. This suggests that they may pass on the relatively sparse floral resources of the grasslands until the Fall, when dense and attractive patches of goldenrod and aster bloom – potentially providing them an important source of resources as pickings become slim late in the season.

Most excitingly, our collections have revealed 39 unique genera of bees and hoverflies in the grasslands, so far – with more likely to be found as we continue to identify the many insects from our collections. Our efforts have also found several rare bee and hoverfly species; some of which are insects that have never been observed in Baltimore County! Among these rare and interesting finds are two bees and a hoverfly that are particularly special.

The hoverfly, Trichopsomyia litoralis, is relatively new to science – having only been described in 2019. Not much is known about the ecology of this species, but its larvae are known to feed on economically important pests. Encountering this species in the Serpentine grasslands is interesting not only because it is rarely observed, but also because it is currently thought to only inhabit an eastern coastal range (likely associated with sandy sites)! This information could extend our understanding of this hoverfly’s distribution or suggest that these flies undertake long migrations during their life cycle.

On the other hand, we have found two rare bee species that are really cool: the mining bee, Andrena gardineri; and the nomad bee Nomada seneciophila. These bees are what we call specialists: they have very specific ecological requirements. For example, A. gardineri is known to preferentially forage for pollen on plants from the genus Packera (ragworts or groundsels) – it is considered a Packera specialist. Even though A. gardineri is quite rare in the region, we find it commonly during our spring grassland collections. This is because almost all the conserved grassland areas provide good conditions to host lots of Packera anonyma.

close-up of the face of a bee found in the Maryland Serpentine Grasslands
A close-up shot of a fluffy male Andrena gardineri specimen. Photo: USGS Bee Monitoring Lab / Brooke Alexander. CC 2.0

The other notable bee we observed, the nomad bee, Nomada seneciophila is a vanishingly rare cuckoo bee (see here what these bees do and why this is fascinating). These bees wander (nomadically so) around in search of other bee’s nests so they can hijack them for their own young to develop in! N. seneciophila, as it turns out, is a specialist of our specialist friend, A. gardineri. That is, this nomad bee species has a very strong preference for stealing the nests of our other rare bee, A. gardineri!

another bee found in the Maryland Serpentine Grasslands
The waspy-looking Nomad bee: Nomada seneciophila. Photo: Justin O’Neill

From these interesting encounters, it is becoming increasingly clear that these grasslands not only support remarkable plants; they also provide critical resources and nesting habitat for rare bee and hoverfly species. Although these once expansive ecosystems might not exist on the grand scale they once did, their remnants are unique contributors to the region’s biodiversity. Taking the time to document their floristic and faunistic wonders is important for understanding the historic role they played in shaping regional biodiversity today, and how that biodiversity may respond to the changing environments of the future!

By Justin O’Neill, Ph.D. student, and Dr. Anahí Espíndola, Assistant Professor, EspíndoLab, Department of Entomology, University of Maryland, College Park.

Serpentine Soils Are Anything But Barren: They Support a Unique Grassland Habitat

I have never been to the African grasslands, where lions, zebras, elephants, and wildebeests seem to be in continuous danger. I have, however, been to a Maryland habitat that few people know about, and that, even though lion-, zebra-, elephant- and wildebeest-less, reminded me strongly of those African savannas.

This habitat I am talking about is the Serpentine Grasslands (or Barrens) of the Eastern United States. If you have never heard of them, fear not! Hopefully, by the end of today’s post, you will know a bit more about them and you’ll even try to go visit the few remains that still exist of this beautiful but endangered habitat of our region.

Serpentine Barren Grassland
Fig. 1 – The Serpentine Grasslands of Maryland at Soldiers Delight. Photo: U. Weber.

As you may have guessed from its name, Serpentine Grasslands or Barrens are prairies where the dominant plants are grasses. This is all good, but if they are grasslands, why are they also called Barrens, you may be asking yourself. The answer to that question is what in my opinion makes these habitats so fascinating; something that is also hidden in the other part of their name: “Serpentine”. Indeed, the word Serpentine refers to the type of soil these grasslands are on.

Serpentine soils form on a type of bedrock called serpentinite. This type of rock only exists in places where tectonic plates come into contact, fold, and volcanic activity occurs. This happened in our area about 480 million years ago when the Appalachian Mountains formed. Because of this, there is now an arc of serpentinite present in the Maryland-Pennsylvania area, parallel to the mountains.

Serpentine Soil
Fig. 2 – The Serpentine Grasslands have usually bare soils that have a greenish tint, due to the serpentinite they originate from. Photo: A. Espíndola.

Serpentinites are rich in many metals and other compounds that make the soils that form on top of them relatively toxic and unfriendly to many plants. Because not many plants can grow on these soils, not much soil is retained and the ground ends up being rocky. Because of this characteristic, places with these soils are not very fertile, and, when the Europeans arrived in the area, they started referring to them as ‘barren’, since they were not only infertile, they also had no timber on them. However, even though they were referred to as barrens, many plants do grow on these thin soils, and actually, many of Maryland’s rare flower plants and grasses are adapted to grow in this habitat!

Indeed, the Serpentine Grasslands of Maryland and Pennsylvania are some of the unique places where it is possible to find, for example, the rare moss pink, serpentine aster, or the sandplain gerardia (Fig. 3). It is also home to several endangered and rare species of butterflies and moths such as the Dusted or the Cobweb Skipper (Fig. 4).

Even though the plants and butterflies present in this habitat are relatively well-studied, we still know very little about what other organisms live in the grasslands. To remediate this, in my lab at the University of Maryland in College Park, we are working on trying to understand better what species of insects are present in the area.

Plants of the Serpentine Barron
Fig. 3 – Many rare plants are present in the Serpentine Grasslands of the Eastern US. For example, the moss pink (left; Photo: J. Gallagher) and the sandplain gerardia (right; Photo: A. Espíndola).

For the moment, we are focusing on insect pollinators, and our first works indicate that the plants growing in these grasslands are pollinated not only by bees but also by hoverflies, showing how important these lesser-known pollinators may be to sustaining a very rare habitat of our region. (Take a look here to learn more about hoverflies as pollinators.

The Serpentine Grasslands had not always been rare and endangered. Indeed, serpentine soils extended for quite an area in the Maryland-Pennsylvania region. So, what happened to this habitat that made it so rare today? Ecologists and historians can help us with this.

Like many habitats dominated by grasses, Serpentine Grasslands need fire to sustain themselves. In the absence of fire, pines and red cedars from the surrounding areas start establishing in the grasslands and compete with the grasses and all the rare plants, making the once grassland become an encroached pine forest. When the Europeans first arrived in our region, documents said that there were Serpentine Grasslands that extended for at least 130,000 acres. Today, Serpentine Grasslands occupy about 1.6% of that area.

These grasslands were managed as hunting grounds by several tribes (Susquehannock, Shawnees, Lenape Delaware), who burned them regularly to maintain the grasses and attract large herbivores to hunt. These tribes had complex systems of rights over these lands, which they shared with neighboring tribes as needed. Records show that these extensive grasslands were extremely rich in fauna. There were myriad birds species (mentioned in some records to ‘have darkened the sky’ when migrating!), wolves, bears, cougars, deer, and buffalo roaming these regions!

European colonizers quickly realized that these grasslands were great land for cattle and hunting, and thus started settling and claiming the native tribes’ lands. However, the new inhabitants did not continue the practice of burning, which led to the habitat starting to degrade and finally becoming less appropriate for cattle and cropping.

Eventually, these lands were relegated as ‘useless’ lands and were thus prime land for building or just reinvaded by pines and other trees, which were used for timber. I sometimes try to imagine what these lands — today just 30 minutes away from my house — may have looked like with those large fascinating animals living right here.

Dusted Skipper
Fig. 4 – The Serpentine Barrens are the habitat for several rare moth and butterfly species, such as the Dusted Skipper (Photo: A. Wells).

Today, the Serpentine Barrens are protected and managed with fire in several parts of the state. A large part of these protected lands are not open to the public. However, we are lucky that some places are indeed accessible to the public and can be visited throughout the year.

The largest remnant of Serpentine Grasslands on the Eastern Coast of the US is west of Baltimore, in the Soldiers Delight Natural Environment Area. Another public land where some remains of Serpentine Grasslands are still visible is in Northern Baltimore, at Lake Roland.

I am lucky enough that I can visit and work in these fascinating places. If you have never been to them and would like to see these local jewels, take me up on the invitation and consider hiking some of their trails. The spring and summer are gorgeous on these lands, and who knows, you may be lucky enough to see one of those rare beauties that still live there!

By Anahí Espíndola, Assistant Professor, Department of Entomology, University of Maryland, College Park