A container gardening cautionary tale

In my last post, I mentioned that it’s important to select the correct container size for growing vegetables. In fact, I pointed out that the correct size is nearly always bigger than you think it should be. I think the common error of putting plants in pots too small for them is akin to the instinct that makes us plant them too close together in in-ground gardens. They are just so cute and little when we put them into the ground—how can they possibly turn into hulking monsters with thirsty and enormous root systems? Don’t be fooled! Size up your containers and make your plants happy. (HGIC has a handy set of guidelines.)

It’s not just the size in gallons that matters to successful container selection, though, as my next-door neighbor found out last year. She grows tomato plants in pots on her sunny patio, and has great success. In fact I would say gargantuan success—her plants are huge!

A large tomato plant in a black container, being held up by a wire cage. Many immature green tomatoes are growing on the plant making it even more top heavy.
Photo taken July 22, 2017 – but huge even earlier!

I’m not sure what she does to make the tomatoes grow so tall so fast, while mine are still about half the size in my community garden plot. Soil in pots does tend to be warmer in late spring when the ground temperatures are cool, and my plants catch up over time. Potting soil with plenty of fertilizer included gives plants a fast start, and regular doses of fertilizer keep growth chugging along. Fertilizers with a high percentage of nitrogen produce rampant leaf growth, so that may be part of the equation, though the nutrients must balance out over time since her plants produce plenty of fruit.

In any case, it’s been working out well for her. Until last year. Last summer we had several periods of high winds. The top-heavy tomato plants kept crashing over. In July our neighbors went on vacation and asked us to water their plants, but on the first morning I went over and found the tomatoes on the ground. I ended up creating an arrangement of string, stakes, and cinderblocks to keep them upright.

Three large tomato plant in containers. Cinderblocks are gathered around the containers to help stabilize them. String and simple stakes (like those from a camping tent) are leading from the wire cage to ground to keep the plants upright.

So, container volume isn’t the only consideration—shape matters as well. Containers that are higher than they are wide may not work well with plants that get very tall. My neighbor (who was very grateful for the emergency tomato intervention!) had basically two choices: get new containers (wider, heavier, with a lower center of gravity, like half-barrels), or grow shorter tomato plants.

Therefore, I have introduced her to the Dwarf Tomato Project, and will be growing seedlings for my own use and hers. These dwarf plants, bred for growing in containers, produce tomatoes with real heirloom flavor, but they stay short (heights vary, but most are under four feet). I only have a little experience with these varieties (I figured the Year of Container Gardening was a good time to get more) but like heirloom plants, they’re inconsistent in how many tomatoes they produce over a season; some are prolific and some stingy. So we’ll see how it goes. I’m trying three varieties: Uluru Ochre (which I’ve grown before), Rosella Purple, and Summer Sweet Gold. I’ll also get some full-size plants to mix things up, of course!

The other advantage to dwarf tomato plants is that you don’t need huge containers, but still—I’ll go with the largest ones I own. Other vegetables that grow best in bigger-than-you-think pots include squash (and its relatives like cucumbers and melons), potatoes and sweet potatoes. Size up for success! Also, look at seed catalogs for varieties intended for containers; they will be shorter with smaller root systems and may still be quite prolific while demanding less water. (But remember to water frequently nonetheless.)

Spring is coming, so have your containers ready!!

By Erica Smith, Montgomery County Master Gardener. Read more posts by Erica.

All photos by Erica Smith

3 thoughts on “A container gardening cautionary tale

  1. Wendy March 7, 2026 / 11:31 am

    Thanks for the helpful post. I’m switching my tomatoes from in ground to containers this year, as part of crop rotation. So perfect timing as I consider which containers to use. I’m curious about your neighbor’s tomato cage. Is that DIY? I’d like to try something similar and would like to know more about materials and construction.

    • Erica March 7, 2026 / 12:55 pm

      I don’t know the exact brand, but it’s definitely a commercial product, made out of steel wire (probably 10-gauge?). I think they fold flat for storage. Lots of vendors stock similar ones. Look for something that will fit into your container or possibly over the sides. Good luck!

  2. Lisa March 8, 2026 / 1:22 pm

    Two years ago I became aware of the potential for nano plastics to migrate into our garden-grown vegetables when I was called out by a member of my local gardening group for making DIY earth boxes from plastic storage bins. At first I was skeptical that plastic could actually end up in my vegetables, but the more I researched the more concerned I became. I’d already started getting rid of plastics in my home—especially my kitchen—switching out utensils, storage and even a blender for items made from glass, metal, and silicone.

    As I have always used organic methods to grow all my plants I was rather horrified to look at the amount of plastics in my garden, including plastic pots—and my composter! Since then I’ve slowly switched to raised beds and fabric grow bags, metal cages and stakes, and even purchased a non-plastic hose.

    I suspect that plastics in our environment are potentially a bigger problem than even climate change and dwindling water supplies, which is why I’m commenting here. Studies are showing that plastics and the chemicals they’re made of are present pretty much everywhere on earth, which is really depressing, but awareness is always the first step towards solving a problem; plastic is everywhere in modern life so we take it for granted that it is “safe” but maybe we should no longer make that assumption.

    While it’s an expensive proposition to rid one’s home and garden of plastic, I’d urge people to at least be mindful of it. Personally I feel better about making small changes where I can as I’m certainly not rich; every year I’ve replaced a few items here and there.

    Here’s an article that might be helpful:
    https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10966681/

    Be well, Lisa

Leave a Reply to LisaCancel reply