Leave the Leaves, All While Not Making Your Neighbors Mad

With the fall season we are starting to see a lot of articles talking about the massive ecological and soil quality benefits of leaving leaves, stems, and sticks in our green spaces. As a biologist, I understand why doing so is indeed the right thing to do, but I often face pushback on this topic from people I mention this to through my Extension work or just in my neighborhood. There are of course many barriers to adopting such practices that I have heard people mention, but one that comes up often is the one that involves social or peer pressure. In other words, how to adopt this without making your neighbors mad? In today’s blog, I want to give some pointers to avoid conflict with (and maybe even convince) neighbors who may be less convinced than you on these practices.

Some fall practices that we know are good for biodiversity and your soil

I do not want to talk yet again in depth about these practices (you can read more about it in these other articles if you want to know more):

But I want to just quickly state some of them, so you know what I am referring to throughout this article. I feel that there are three major types of practices that can be adopted for protecting pollinators and other insects during the winter: leaving the fallen leaves on the ground, not pruning certain pithy stems to the ground until the Spring, and making branches and stick piles in sections of your green spaces.

For all these practices, common sense should be used when deciding whether to adopt them or not (e.g., if you are in a fire-prone area, perhaps making huge wood piles is not a good idea), remembering that these are indeed all practices that have been shown to improve biodiversity in our green spaces.

Fallen tree leaves have been spread about fours inches deep in a wide circle around the base of a very large tree in a backyard.  Stones are used to create the circular perimeter and contain the leaves.
Piling the leaves around trees is a good way to retain them in the green space, all while giving an impression of “tidiness” to the yard. Photo: D. Mizejewski.

How to avoid “leaving the leaves” look messy?

So, you want to participate in the ”leave the leaves” action, but you still want to make clear that somebody is actually taking care of it. What to do?

  • If you have the option to ignore others’ opinions, you can just leave the leaves where they fell and go on with your life. 😊 That said, this may or not apply to most people.
  • You can pick certain areas of your green space to leave the leaves, but rake other areas. Perhaps you want to have the areas that are less exposed to people’s eyes be those selected for leaving the leaves. This will show that your leaving the leaves is purposeful and not just a lack of care.
  • If you have trees on your space, you can also decide to pile up the leaves around trees. This will provide shelter to insects and other small critters, provide mulch for the tree, and sign active care of your space.
  • A problem I sometimes hear about is leaves blowing over to another person’s yard or space. To avoid this, you can use plants to line/fence your green space. These plantings will have the positive effects of both allowing your leaves to stay on the ground, while minimizing “spill overs”.
  • Explain what you are doing. You can tell your neighbors about what is going on, and even put a sign up to clarify what is happening (if you want to go “fancy”, the Xerces Society has a neat one).
  • A thing NOT to do if you would like to retain arthropod diversity but also make the leaves look “tidier”, is mow them over. This has been shown to kill the insects that were preparing to overwinter in them. ☹
A "Pollinator Habitat" sign is visible in this part of the landscape where fallen tree leaves are spread about four inches deep in a garden bed. The sign explains that the leaves help overwintering pollinators survive the winter.
Displaying a sign that explains that some activities in our green spaces are creating pollinator habitat can go a long way. Photo: C. Corner.

How to leave the stems without issues

Another practice shown to support stem-nesting insects (including several bees) is not trimming pithy stems all the way down during the fall.

  • If you have the option to ignore others’ opinions, you can just leave the stems and go on with your life. 😊 That said, this may or not apply to most people.
  • As for the leaves, you can select sections of your space where you decide to implement this. An extension of this idea is that perhaps you can reconsider where your plantings are, so you have the pithy plants (e.g., brambles) in areas that you know are not going to be looked at all the time.
  • You can also decide to trim the plants down to some extent (about 2-3 ft from the ground) but not completely. This will show that you are taking care of the plants, but that you actively decided not to trim them all the way down.
  • Letting people know what is going on is always a good thing. You can add a little sign to tell people about what you’re doing and why, and/or you can talk to your neighbors to let them know.
2 foot to 3 foot lengths of tree branches and sticks are piled together in an out-of-the way spot in the yard to provide habitat for insects and other small critters. The pile is surrounded and held up four medium-size sticks stuck in the ground vertically at the corners of the pile.
Make your wood and stick piles look “organized” by defining spaces in your yard that you allocate to creating those biodiversity habitats. Photo: Natural History Museum.

Making a pile of sticks and wood without scaring people

Making stick piles is a very good practice to retain biodiversity in green spaces. That said, people can feel like a pile can look untidy, and even some cities may have some regulations about what type of pile may be OK versus not.

  • If you have the option to ignore others’ opinions, you can just make a pile and go on with your life. 😊 That said, this may or not apply to most people.
  • You can restrict the pile clearly to a specific area of your space, and make clear that you have actively decided to make one and are taking care of it. This is to sign that this is not just some brush you left around after you trimmed some plants, but actually a specific green space feature you are trying to build.
  • You can make it look cute. Check out this other blog, A Brilliant Fall Banquet, where some ideas are given.
  • Information, information, information. Let people know what this is and why you are doing it. And also, if there are some afraid of snakes or fires, make sure that the area you live is not known for its high fire or venomous snake danger (you can inform yourself about these topics online or ask an Extension agent; e.g., Venomous Snakes of Maryland.

By Anahí Espíndola, Associate Professor, Department of Entomology, University of Maryland, College Park. See more posts by Anahí.

Anahí also writes an Extension Blog in Spanish! Check it out here, 
extensionesp.umd.edu, and please share and spread the word to your Spanish-speaking friends and colleagues in Maryland. ¡Bienvenidos a Extensión en Español!

4 thoughts on “Leave the Leaves, All While Not Making Your Neighbors Mad

  1. George Lambert November 17, 2024 / 4:43 pm

    I wish writers would stop and think how good intentions could have adverse consequences, presumably through misapplication. In this case, I didn’t notice any differentiation between leaves in the garden vs. in the lawn. While many of us think we have way too much soil in lawns, we should not mistreat what is there, and leaving leaves there is not constructive. I also lament that pro-leaves writers never mention that shredded leaves 1) look much better, 2) don’t blow around as much (particularly if soak them in), and 3) break down into the soil quicker. Electric shredders are great investments for those with a bunch of large trees.

    • Developer December 23, 2024 / 3:04 am

      I completely understand your concerns and appreciate your thoughtful perspective. It’s true that leaving leaves on the lawn can sometimes have unintended consequences, especially when it comes to maintaining healthy grass and soil. As you mentioned, the buildup of leaves can smother the lawn, preventing sunlight and air from reaching the grass, which could lead to issues like thinning or dead patches.

      Shredding leaves is indeed a great solution, not only because it enhances the appearance of your lawn but also because it allows for quicker decomposition and better integration into the soil. Shredded leaves can provide excellent mulch, helping to retain moisture, add organic matter, and protect plants from harsh weather. Additionally, as you pointed out, soaking them can help prevent them from blowing around, which is especially useful in areas with strong winds.

      Electric shredders are a fantastic investment for those with large yards, as they make the process faster and more efficient. Ultimately, it’s all about balancing environmental practices with the specific needs of your garden and lawn. Thanks for sharing your thoughts—it’s great to have a discussion on how we can best care for our outdoor spaces while considering both aesthetics and functionality!

      If you want to know more about MagisTV IPTV then visit https://themagistv.com/

    • Sophia Caldwell March 2, 2025 / 11:47 am

      I really appreciate this post! It was clear, helpful, and well-explained. Thanks for taking the time to share your knowledge.

    • KD McLynn November 17, 2025 / 3:49 pm

      Shredding leaves does make them tidier, less apt to blow around and less bulky for use as a ground cover. Using a mulching blade on the lawn mower all fall can help keep leaves from building up. However, shredding is also extremely hard on insects that overwinter in the leaves. So ideal would be a both/and approach that combined use of shredded leaves as mulch, but also included large amounts of unshredded leaves to preserve wildlife in the landscape, such as wire ovals behind some shrubs, etc.

Leave a Reply to Sophia CaldwellCancel reply